| Agnes | Paige Blosser |
| Tilly | Zoe Howell |
| Chuck | Liam McChesney |
| Miles | Gabe Legg |
| Kaliope | Erin Kubat |
| Lilith | Ellie DeBeer |
| Vera/Beholder | Regan Baird |
| Evil Gabbi | Maya Wilkinson |
| Evil Tina | Ariel Bailey |
| Farrah the Faerie | Brian Cloutier |
| Steve | Ryan Gipson-Halstead |
| Orcus | Tristan Collins |
| Kelly | Tessa Corcoran |
| Lilly | Becka McVey |
| Ronnie | Zac Streeter |
| Monsters | Brooke Anderson |
| Cooper Atchison | |
| Brooke Beggins | |
| Coltan Daly | |
| Basia Dziekan | |
| AJ Giron | |
| Meg Johnson |
